News › Policy
Policy
A US judge acquits the MEV brothers in the first criminal case over a blockchain exploit: Ethereum has “no terms of use”
Judge Jessica Clarke cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and money laundering conspiracy charges over a $25 million trade, after the jury deadlocked a year ago.


A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted two MIT-educated brothers of fraud charges over a trade on Ethereum that prosecutors said earned them $25 million in 12 seconds. According to CoinDesk, Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on 16 November on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, and directed the clerk to close the case. The ruling comes about a year after the jury deadlocked and a mistrial was declared in November 2025, a result The Block covered at the time under the headline “Massive overstep”.
The case was described as the US government’s first criminal case over an MEV exploit. MEV, maximal extractable value, is the profit available to whoever controls the order of transactions in a block. In a sandwich attack a bot sees a large pending buy, buys first, lets the victim’s trade lift the price, then sells. The brothers, in April 2023, turned that against the bots. They placed eight bait transactions, and when their own validator was up, a relay offered it a block containing the bots’ sandwich trades. The validator signed the block header with two key fields set to zero, which made the block invalid, but the relay did not check and released the contents anyway. The brothers then built their own block that kept the bots’ purchases but replaced the bait with transactions that dumped the tokens, so the market crashed before the bots could sell. The bots lost about $25 million, and the brothers’ validator was penalized about 1 ether.
Why was it not fraud? Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation, a lie that matters to the person deceived. Clarke wrote that “no trader who places a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched,” and that the government offered no evidence that a pending trade amounts to a promise not to be bundled. The falsified signature also had no effect, because the relay never checked the fields. She described Ethereum as “a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.”
The judge did not praise the conduct. She acknowledged that the brothers concealed their plans and may have undermined the spirit of the relay software’s design, citing a 2022 Second Circuit ruling that conduct that is “improper, objectionable, or even despicable” is not enough for wire fraud. The question, she wrote, was whether the conduct was wire fraud, not whether it was right or moral.
Some details remain open. The bot operators, who were themselves running sandwich trades, face no criminal case, and only one wallet, holding about $3 million of the proceeds, was frozen. The brothers had moved the rest of the money out by October 2023.
For anyone building or using open networks, the takeaway is narrow but real: a court has said that exploiting how a public system actually works, without lying to anyone who relied on it, is not automatically a crime. It is a US district ruling in one case, and it does not tell us how other courts or regulators will treat similar behavior.
Facts only, never financial advice.